Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pie Pink Owl Kitchen Diluting Greek yogurt worked well to create buttermilk and kefir substitutes (which performed nearly identically to buttermilk in our Best Buttermilk Pancakes recipe). Because different brands of Primitive Vapor Butter Milk Pie Vape Juice & E Liquid Store Southern Buttermilk Pie Kevin Is Cooking Classic Buttermilk Pie Recipe with VIDEO